The life cycle of a Google {hardware} product normally takes one among two instructions: it begins filled with bugs and slowly, with software program updates, finally ends up being a stable product with a whiff of status harm; or it begins seemingly flawless and, over time, loses its luster as small points crop up and do not get solved.
The corporate’s first true wi-fi earbuds, 2020’s Pixel Buds, had been the latter. In April 2020, because the pandemic began raging throughout the nation, Google appeared triumphant as early opinions praised the earbuds’ sound high quality, consolation, and common ease of use. But it surely grew to become rapidly obvious that customers would uncover endemic connectivity points as they spent extra time carrying their new buds. Google chalked it as much as early firmware and promised fixes, however even after a number of updates, the issues have but to totally abate — even at this time, Google’s assist boards are filled with posts concerning the Pixel Buds’ choppiness.
For that purpose, I waited so long as attainable to evaluation the brand new Pixel Buds A-Collection, which Google says it has inoculated towards related connectivity issues in a number of essential methods. The excellent news is that after greater than two weeks of each day use out and in of the house, in areas the place the unique Pixel Buds at all times give hassle, the A-Collection, regardless of their cheaper price, have but to expertise a lot as a crackle or dropout. The higher information is that, however for a few options, the Pixel Buds A-Collection are practically equivalent to the Pixel Buds in all of its optimistic attributes.
That makes these, at $100, one of many best true wireless earbuds you should buy — so long as you’re OK with a number of notable compromises.
Google Pixel Buds A-Collection: Value and availability
The Pixel Buds A-Collection had been introduced on June 3, 2021, and launched on June 17 within the US and Canada. Extra international locations will likely be added to the roster within the coming months. Accessible for $100 USD and $140 CAD, the Pixel Buds A-Collection debuted $80 cheaper than their Pixel Buds counterparts, although the older, costlier mannequin is obtainable cheaper at some retailers.
You will get the Pixel Buds A-Collection in 4 colorways: Clearly White, Darkish Olive, Charcoal, and Sea. Because the unique launch, Google hasn’t seen the necessity to provide an upgraded iteration of those earbuds, and most just lately launched the Sea coloration possibility following the announcement of the Pixel 7a at I/O 2023.
Google Pixel Buds A-Collection: {Hardware} and design
The Pixel Buds A-Collection look nearly precisely just like the 2020 Pixel Buds, which implies they give the impression of being very very similar to true wi-fi earbuds designed by Google. The rounded plastic exterior, full with a “G” emblem, is totally touch-sensitive, permitting for single, double, and triple faucets — although, not like final yr’s mannequin, no swipes for quantity adjustment.
With the A-Collection, Google’s gone with a much less contrast-heavy coloration palette, which is ok, however what I am much less enamored of is the cheap-looking shiny plastic, each on the buds themselves and the within of the in any other case well-designed case.
Picture 1 of 3
The buds slot in my ears completely, and I might enterprise to say they are going to slot in yours simply as properly, too. That is as a result of Google is, along with providing three silicon tip sizes, insisting on the location of a everlasting “fin” that sits contained in the ear concha, maintaining the bud from shifting round. In my carrying, these proved to be, like their predecessors, among the many most snug earbuds I’ve ever worn for lengthy durations, with a whole absence of ache or fatigue.
The venting makes these among the many most snug earbuds I’ve ever worn, however that consolation comes on the expense of isolation.
That is partly as a result of earbud’s semi-open design; whereas sticking them in your ear canal produces a seal, there’s a vent on the underside of every bud that releases a few of that conventional strain brought on by conventional closed earbuds. It is a compromise, although, as a result of that vent additionally means the Pixel Buds let in additional exterior noise than a lot of its rivals, which, mixed with an absence of energetic noise cancelation, make them much less appropriate for some loud environments. The buds are IPX4 rated, too, which makes them acceptable for exercises and different out of doors actions, however I would not threat a dip within the pool or some other type of immersion.
Google did not mess with a superb factor when it got here to the case, which although a number of grams lighter (the buds themselves are barely lighter too), continues to be an incredible fidget toy because of the satisfying magnetic clunk of the lid. The earbuds relaxation gently of their charging cradles, and whereas the case lacks wi-fi charging, they prime up comparatively rapidly over USB-C.
Google Pixel Buds A-Collection: Sound high quality & options
Regardless of the A-Collection’ $100 value level, Google did not compromise on the sound high quality. I requested the corporate whether or not they used the identical 12mm drivers because the costlier Pixel Buds and acquired a affirmation, however the sound signatures aren’t equivalent. I am glad I am not the one one who skilled this — different reviewers mentioned the identical factor — although I would not go as far as to say the earbuds sound “hole” like I learn at a number of different locations.
The Pixel Buds A-Collection have a impartial sound signature that does not emphasize bass, which may come throughout as tonally underwhelming or boring relying on the supply materials. However the default equalization additionally means they don’t seem to be fatiguing, and the A-Collection shipped with the identical “Bass Increase” characteristic that finally got here to the common Pixel Buds final August. That little low-end bump does wonders for hip-hop and home music, although I would not essentially advocate these in case your main concern is large, thumpy digital tracks.
However in December 2021, Google introduced out few new features to the Pixel Buds A-Collection, which included further bass controls. With a slider that may be adjusted from -1 to +4, there may be the potential of twice as a lot bass as was out there beforehand utilizing the straightforward “Bass Increase” toggle.
To save lots of a number of {dollars}, Google eliminated one of many Pixel Buds’ sensors when designing the A-Collection, and there is additionally one fewer microphone. Sadly, meaning you lose out on the so-called Consideration Alerts, which stand in for a standard transparency mode on the Pixel Buds. I by no means actually discovered Consideration Alerts all that helpful, although, restricted as they’re to “child crying, canine barking, and emergency automobile siren,” based on the August 2020 documentation.
These are as plug-and-play because it will get on an Android cellphone, and the sound high quality is simply as accessible, although it will not blow you away.
The sensor removing would not have an effect on any of the A-Collection’ talents, although: there’s nonetheless auto-play/pause when one bud is eliminated, which I really like, and always-on Google Assistant continues to be one of many Buds’ marquee options — extra obligatory now as a result of it is the one approach to modify quantity with out utilizing your cellphone. Word, although, that when Google Assistant is enabled, there is not any approach to fully disable the “ping” that arrives with an incoming notification — you’ll be able to disable the assistant from studying them as they arrive in, however you are caught together with your supply decreasing in quantity barely for an prompt every time your coworker messages you on Slack. Not ultimate.
I spent lots of time utilizing a single Pixel Bud for Google Meet calls linked to my MacBook, or strolling exterior listening to podcasts, and actually loved the expertise. Callers instructed me that the sound high quality was “AirPod-level,” which I discover troublesome to imagine, however I recorded myself and performed it again, and whereas I would not essentially agree, it is shut sufficient. Positively up there with Apple and Jabra.
What Google is lacking in comparison with these costlier earbuds, and even some on the $100 mark, is energetic noise cancelation. As nice and clean-sounding because the A-Collection are, in the event you’re utilizing them in noisy environments, there are in all probability higher choices on the market.
Google Pixel Buds A-Collection: Connectivity & battery life
I will be trustworthy: I wished to attend a number of weeks after receiving the Pixel Buds A-Collection as a result of I acquired burned when utilizing the Buds simply over a yr in the past. So once I first began testing them, like everybody else, I had a fairly flawless expertise. But it surely rapidly grew to become obvious there have been hardware-related connectivity points that flared up in areas of excessive 2.4Ghz interference. To at the present time, after half a dozen firmware updates, I can not reliably use the Pixel Buds exterior with out fixed cutouts and syncing issues.
Fortunately, the A-Collection solves the Pixel Buds’ largest challenge: instability.
These points had been brought on by how the Buds linked to their supply: the fitting bud linked to the cellphone, and the left one routed by the fitting one as in a relay. This was once the way in which all true wi-fi earbuds linked to telephones and computer systems, and whereas that did not essentially pose connectivity hassle, it definitely elevated the chance in areas of interference or the place the sign wasn’t robust sufficient for the relay to be maintained.
Google instructed Android Central that they mounted these issues in two methods, first by utilizing a stronger amplifier than within the previous-gen mannequin, and second by routing every bud independently to the cellphone. And I am joyful to say it labored. After two weeks of each day listening, I’ve but to have a single second of crosstalk or interference, and never one disconnection.
The place I have not seen any enchancment over the unique Pixel Buds is battery life. Every bud is rated for 5 hours, and the case provides a further 19 hours. That is a nice quantity, however I hoped that Google may eke an additional hour or two with a extra environment friendly chip powering them. Alas, 5 hours is all you get.
Lastly, I need to speak about Quick Pair. Now the Pixel Buds are clearly not the one Quick Pair-enabled true wi-fi earbuds, however they work extraordinarily reliably on any Android cellphone you open the case close to. Your cellphone detects their presence, they rapidly pair, and on a Pixel cellphone, the app is already preloaded, and also you’re able to go; on one other Android cellphone, you are required to obtain the Pixel Buds app to vary options.
Google Pixel Buds A-Collection: Competitors
The under-$100 tier of the true wi-fi earbud market has exploded over the previous couple of years, as upward strain from Amazon-first corporations within the low-end — Tozo and Anker, amongst many others — meet downward strain from last-generation model names — Samsung and Jabra — within the high-end.
At $100, the Samsung Galaxy Buds 2 are the closest well-known competitor to the Pixel Buds, providing an identical strategy by way of sound and Android integration, although clearly extra extremely optimized for Samsung gadgets. I discover the Buds 2 far much less snug than the Pixel Buds A-Collection, and Bixby is much much less helpful than Google Assistant, however the Samsung product practically doubles the battery lifetime of the Google ones, they usually have a correct transparency mode, together with wi-fi charging.
If you wish to maintain the consolation however add ANC, Anker’s Soundcore model has so much to supply. I actually just like the Jabra Elite 4 earbuds, additionally $100 proper now, which supply an identical in-ear design however sound fuller than the A-Collection, particularly within the low-end, and have extra customization because of an EQ personalization characteristic within the app. Plus, they’ve very respectable energetic noise cancelation.
Lastly, you would possibly simply be higher served by saving a number of extra doubloons and grabbing the Pixel Buds Pro. These had been launched in July 2022 and have develop into a staple for a lot of in search of the most effective wi-fi earbuds. You will get pleasure from every part from unbelievable battery life to a well-recognized match, and there is even multipoint connectivity built-in. However the most effective half is that the Buds Professional can often be discovered on sale for between $140 and $160, and we might go as far as to say that the additional couple of bucks is value it.
Google Pixel Buds A-Collection: Do you have to purchase it?
You can purchase this if …
- You desire a snug pair of true wi-fi earbuds for an Android cellphone
- You need always-on Google Assistant
- You need clear, accessible sound high quality with out boominess
- You need to keep away from the connectivity issues of the Pixel Buds (2020)
You should not purchase this if …
- You want energetic noise cancelation
- You want all-day battery life
- You need aptX codec assist
I will be trustworthy: I did not anticipate liking the Pixel Buds A-Collection as a lot as I do. Granted, the 2020 Pixel Buds nailed lots of the basics, however at $180, they caught out as missing one characteristic, ANC, that a lot of its rivals had been already jamming in for a similar value. That and the endemic connectivity points (which persist at this time) made me cautious of a successor. Retaining many of the core options that made the 2020 Pixel Buds so good, fixing the dropouts, and dropping the worth to $100 was sufficient for me to present these an unqualified suggestion.
Google Pixel Buds A-Collection
Nonetheless an unbelievable worth
At $100, Google’s Pixel Buds A-Collection reside as much as the value-but-not-cheap status solid by the Pixel A cellphone line. Wonderful sound and luxury mixed with helpful options like always-on Google Assistant and an excellent onboarding expertise forgive an absence of wi-fi charging and energetic noise cancelation.